Monday Market Update: Scottsdale Stands Alone
MARKET · NOVEMBER 16, 2026
Monday Market Update: Scottsdale Stands Alone
Paradise Valley fell out of the seller's band and Phoenix slipped into buyer's territory this week, which leaves Scottsdale as the only one of the eighteen cities tracked that still reads above 110. The mid-month numbers put the median sale price at $445,000, its lowest since January, with the fewest homes under contract for any mid-month in a year. Also this week: a hot inflation report pushed the ten year Treasury back above 5%, and the index's slide slowed for a third straight week.
The Signal
Scottsdale is now the only one of the eighteen cities tracked here where sellers hold a clear advantage.Paradise Valley fell 7.1 points on the week to 105.4, the largest weekly move in the table and a 19% decline over the past month, and dropped out of the band above 110 that marks a seller's market; it read 212.1 in late August and has given up half of that in eleven weeks. That leaves Scottsdale, at 125.9, more than 20 points clear of every other city, though it is down 14% over the past month itself. Two more cities crossed the other line: Cave Creek at 89.5 and Phoenix at 89.0 both slipped under 90, the level where conditions begin to favor buyers. The count now stands at one seller's market, four balanced cities (Paradise Valley, Chandler, Avondale, and Fountain Hills), and thirteen buyer's markets, from two, five, and eleven a week ago. Only Scottsdale, Paradise Valley, and Chandler still read above 100. The valley-wide Cromford Market Index, which measures the balance between supply and demand rather than prices, fell to 63.1, its tenth straight weekly decline, against 71.7 a month ago, 78.4 a year ago, and 87.7 two years ago. The slide is losing speed, though. This week's drop of 1.2 points was the smallest since late September, after 2.3, 2.1, and 1.8 in the three weeks before it. Three cities rose on the week, Avondale for the second week running along with Tempe and Maricopa, and the average decline across the eighteen cities over the past month eased to about 13.5% after three weeks near 15%. Slower is not the same as over: fifteen of the eighteen cities still fell on the week, and all eighteen read lower than they did a month ago.
Prices have been slower to move than the index, and the mid-month numbers show both halves of that. In the month ending November 15, the median closed price per square foot for the whole market was $250.74, a gain of 0.1% from mid-October and its first rise after three straight monthly declines, though it still sits 1.8% under the same period last year, a wider gap than the 1.0% of a month ago. Four weeks ago this update read the contracts then in the pipeline as pointing to closed prices holding near flat into mid-November, and on price per square foot that is what happened. The median sale price went the other way, to $445,000 from $450,000 a month earlier and the same $450,000 a year ago, a 1.1% decline on both counts and the lowest mid-month figure since January. The average price per square foot dropped 1.2% to $297.30 even though homes at $1 million and above grew to 11.0% of closings and 33.5% of the dollars, from 10.0% and 33.0%. More of the sales were expensive homes, and the average fell anyway. The contracts that will close over the next month look softer than the ones that just did. Homes under contract on November 15 carried a median list price of $254.17 per square foot, 0.6% lower than a month before, and there were only 5,995 of them: 7% fewer than in mid-October, 21% fewer than a year ago, and the smallest mid-month count in the past twelve months. The calendar rarely helps here; over the last decade, price per square foot has moved an average of about 0.1% between mid-November and mid-December. Taken together, that points to closed prices that are flat at best through mid-December and more likely a little lower. One more number to track: 94.4% of the homes under contract are ordinary sales, 1.6% are bank owned, and 4.0% are in pre-foreclosure, against 94.6%, 1.5%, and 3.9% a month ago. The ordinary share has not been this low since October 2017. Distress is still small by any historical measure, but its share of the pipeline has nearly doubled in a year, from 2.9% to 5.6%.
The Week in One Box
One seller's market left: Scottsdale at 125.9 · Paradise Valley 105.4, down 7.1 points on the week · Four balanced cities, thirteen buyer's markets · Cromford Market Index 63.1, tenth straight weekly decline and the smallest since late September · Median sale price $445,000 at mid-month, lowest since January · 5,995 homes under contract at mid-month, fewest in a year · 30 year fixed 7.11% in the weekly survey, 7.50% on the daily index
The Numbers
Active listings excluding those under contract stand at 28,269, up 10.0% from a year ago and 3.8% from a month ago, but only 44 more than a week ago after a gain of about 400 the week before. Listings under contract rose for a second straight week to 6,067, still 18.7% below a year ago, and pending listings came in at 3,652, down 15.1%. Sales per month fell to 4,754, down 21.9% from a year ago and about 16% from a month ago. Days on market for sales slipped back to 84 from 86 a week ago, against 83 a year ago. Months of supply excluding under contract edged up to 5.9 from 4.8 a month ago and 4.2 a year ago, and days of inventory reached 137 from 130.
The average sale price was $602,291, up 2.0% from a year ago but down from $617,685 a month ago and lower for a second straight week, and the median was $444,980, down 1.1% from $450,000 a year ago. The average sale price as a share of list was 97.26%, a shade under last year's 97.35%. Monthly dollar volume fell to $2.86B, down 20.4%. Monthly appreciation per square foot slowed to 0.8% against 1.3% a year ago, a drop of 0.5 points, and from 2.0% a week ago and 4.0% two weeks ago, with the average price per square foot at $296.43. The listing success rate was 60.5%, against 67.2% a month ago and 67.6% a year ago. Across the eighteen cities tracked, one is a seller's market, four are balanced, and thirteen favor buyers, from two, five, and eleven a week ago; three cities read above 100 and fifteen below it.
What This Means for the High End
For the high end, the story this week is the gap. As summer ended, the valley's strongest readings belonged to its luxury markets: Paradise Valley read 212.1 in late August, Fountain Hills 193.4 in early September, and Scottsdale 159.1 in mid-September. Today Paradise Valley is at 105.4, Fountain Hills is at 91.8, and Cave Creek, at 89.5, has crossed into buyer's territory. Scottsdale has fallen too, by 21% from that mid-September reading and by 14% over the past month, but at 125.9 it is the one luxury market where a well-prepared seller still negotiates from strength. That lead is real, and it is not permanent. Scottsdale lost about four points this week; at that pace, which has varied from week to week and is arithmetic rather than a prediction, it would reach 110 in roughly four weeks. A seller in North Scottsdale should read this as a window that is still open and getting narrower. A seller in Paradise Valley should read it as a market that now rewards the best-presented homes and makes the rest wait.
The second point is what the mid-month numbers say about who is still buying. Homes at $1 million and above made up 11.0% of closings and 33.5% of the dollars in the month ending November 15, both higher than a month earlier, and they were 13.9% of the homes under contract on the 15th, up from 12.7%. Run the arithmetic on the contract counts and it comes to roughly 830 homes at that level under contract, against about 815 a month ago, while everything below $1 million fell by more than 400, or about 8%. Put plainly, the entire decline in homes under contract over the past month came from below $1 million. The upper end is not growing, but it is holding while the middle shrinks, which is why the average sale price is still 2.0% above last year while the median is 1.1% below it. Two cautions go with that. The average has now slipped two weeks in a row, to $602,291 from $623,306, and appreciation per square foot has slowed from 4.0% to 0.8% over the same two weeks. And the average list price per square foot under contract rose 3.4% in a month while the median fell 0.6%, a gap that reflects the mix of what is selling more than any gain in what a given home is worth. For homes over $1 million, the takeaway is that about as many of them are under contract as a month ago, and with Paradise Valley, Fountain Hills, and Cave Creek all weaker, the buyers writing those contracts have more room to be selective about which homes they choose.
The third point is what a seller can still control as leverage moves away. With thirteen of eighteen cities favoring buyers and the fewest homes under contract for any mid-month in a year, buyers are choosing from a longer list, and two things decide which listings they choose: price and condition. Price has to be set against the contracts being written today, not last summer's closings. Condition is where the gap between listings is widest, because a buyer with choices tends to pass over the dated kitchen and the worn flooring, or to discount them by more than the work itself would run. Every buyer and seller who works with me gets My Exclusive Renovation Offer: I cover the labor for the renovations, and materials are the client's responsibility. For a seller, that means the work is finished before the photos, so the home competes with the best listings in its bracket instead of waiting on a price reduction. For a buyer, it means the listing that has sat because it needs work becomes the one worth negotiating on. Sellers walk out with more money. Buyers walk in with more equity.
What to Watch
Inflation came in hotter than forecast, and the bond market repriced for it. October consumer prices rose 0.4% for the month against an expected 0.3%, and the core rate, which leaves out food and energy, rose 0.3% for a third straight month against an expected 0.2%. As noted here last week, the report carried no official annual rate; that returns with the November report on December 10. Producer prices added to the picture, up 6.5% from a year ago, the largest annual gain since November 2022. The same day as the consumer report, Fed Governor Christopher Waller said he leans toward a quarter-point increase in December and that a half point deserves consideration if core inflation keeps printing at 0.3% or more. Futures now treat an increase on December 9 as certain, from roughly 80% a week ago, with about one chance in nine that it is a half point. The ten year Treasury closed Friday at 5.14%, up from 4.86% a week earlier, and the two year rose by more. Mortgage rates are telling two stories at once. Freddie Mac's weekly survey, released Thursday, put the 30 year fixed at 7.11%, a fourth straight weekly decline and the lowest since late September. The daily lender index from Mortgage News Daily, which reacts faster, ended Friday at 7.50%, up a third of a point on the week, which erased most of October's improvement. Unless bonds rally early this week, Thursday's survey should move up toward the daily number. Oil was not the driver this time: Brent finished the week near $96, slightly lower. On the calendar: retail sales on Tuesday, then housing starts and the minutes of the Fed's October meeting on Wednesday. Further out, three dates sit back to back: the Fed decision on December 9, the November inflation report on December 10, and the December 11 expiration of federal funding, which is also the day the National Flood Insurance Program's authorization runs out unless Congress extends it.
For Phoenix, this week's local numbers and this week's rate move point in opposite directions. The local numbers show the first broad signs of the slide slowing: the index's smallest weekly decline since late September, a smaller average monthly decline across the eighteen cities, only 44 more active listings than a week ago, two straight weekly gains in listings under contract, and a price per square foot that stopped falling. Much of that arrived during four weeks of easing mortgage rates, and that support reversed on Tuesday. At the survey rate of 7.11%, principal and interest on an 80% loan against the $444,980 median runs about $2,395 a month; at Friday's daily rate of 7.50% it is about $2,489, or $94 more, and both are roughly $200 to $300 above the same payment a year ago. If you are buying, thirteen of the eighteen cities now favor you and sellers are accepting about 97% of list on average; the variable to manage is the rate, so talk to your lender about lock terms before you write an offer, because the daily rate is moving faster than the weekly headline. If you are selling, respect the contract count: fewer buyers are choosing among more homes, and the homes that go under contract are the ones priced against what is being written now and finished well enough to stand out. In Scottsdale that math is still more forgiving than anywhere else in the valley. In Paradise Valley it changed this week.
Buying or Selling?
See If You Qualify for the Renovation Program
Source: Cromford Associates LLC
Recent Posts









